This blog has two functions.
1. I would like to share my story about transitioning from a very pro-school public school teacher into an unschooler.
2. I would like to share some "Learning Units" designed by my child during his unschooling journey.
By themselves the Units are a sort of "tongue in cheek" look at the way educators departmentalize learning. They show that observing what looks like chaos from an educators perspective can actually be highly engaging hands-on lessons tailored to the specific learning needs and interests of individual children. (That was educationese for "If you watch your kids, they are learning by playing")
If you haven't caught on yet, I'm kind of making fun of people who sell curriculum.
There are a lot of different kinds of people in this world.
...and a lot of kinds of kids.
If your kid enjoys having a list of tasks set by someone else and checking off boxes as they go along, this blog is not for you.
If your kid is frustrated about going back to school and wishes they could just learn something interesting for once and you can juggle your schedule at home because now you're telecommuting, this might be interesting.
So... here it goes...
Intrinsically Motivated: Where Play and Learning Become One
So…”Unschooling Curriculum” is an oxymoron. Unschoolers don’t use curriculum. At least they don’t use curriculum designed by adults…or … at least not curriculum that wasn’t chosen by the child… or maybe it was chosen by the adult, but only after an inquiry from the child… or maybe the adult left it in plain view on purpose, but wasn’t pushy about it…oh jeez..this sounds totally confusing.
Off to a great start.
This book (well, now it's a blog) is really a collection of “Learning Units” designed by my child and supported by his community during our unschooling adventure. This is his personal unschooling curriculum. It should look different from any other unschooler’s journey. I’ve organized it to look kind of like the curriculum I was used to using as a classroom teacher. I’m writing it because unschooling has transformed me and my relationship with my child. I am so happy with my choice that I feel compelled to share. I wrote it to look like curriculum because..well…I thought it was funny…but also because I wanted to show how unschooling really can cover a wide range of intellectual and academic learning topics even though it is all child-led learning.
I think I have a unique perspective as an unschooler, because I had 15 years of classroom teaching experience before taking on the challenge to educate my child at home. That, by no means, is meant to imply that I am somehow better suited to educate my own child, or to tell you how to do it. I can just clearly see the differences and similarities as I have been in both places. In fact, I have found that many of the people who choose to unschool their children have experience working in traditional education settings. It is interesting to see so many of these people choosing to educate their own children outside of the schooling norm.
I have often been told things like, “Well of course you can educate your child at home. You have a credential. He’s lucky to have a one on one teacher.” The truth is, my background in education has been the hardest hurdle for me to overcome. This is not an uncommon challenge for teachers who have gone rogue for their own families.
My self-assurance as an unschooling parent did’t just happen in a day… and admittedly, I still have days when I’m not quite sure what I am doing. It took a long time for me to shed my teacher’s mantle. I still struggle with it regularly. Its hard to trust that humans like to learn and that we can find the answers we need as we challenge ourselves to meet intrinsically motivated goals. Its difficult to watch your kid give up on something when you want to see them push through. It’s painful to see them frustrated or taking their time when you know you could give them a strategy to make it all go smoothly, but you don’t because they haven’t asked for your help yet. It’s scary to watch your child make choices that you were never allowed to make as a child yourself. It’s aggravating when your child is being quizzed by relatives to see if he is “up to speed” with the rest of the pack…. But it is absolutely amazing to see them have ownership for their own learning and the confidence to think independently.
As my child began to help me deschool, I found myself wanting to analyze what he was learning in terms of what I had been programmed to teach. I kept going back to the California Department of Education Website to make sure we were covering all of the “required” content standards. I kept observing him like a diligent classroom teacher. Tempted to tick off the boxes in a list created by some education guru from an international conglomerate of an education publishing company paid to research “best practices”.
I found myself justifying his natural tendency to learn by matching up his activities with the “requred learning objectives” set out my national and state education standards. More often than not, my worries became a source of entertainment because he dug way deeper than any normal classroom lesson would have allowed for.
This book (uh blog) is in no way trying to make the case that unschooling is better than school, or that by unschooling your child will be proficient at meeting all required learning standards what ever they may look like where you are from. This book will not help you prep for any tests and will not guarantee college admission. This book is for entertainment and enlightenment purposes only. It is here to help you imagine what unschooling might look like for you and to put you at ease. Hopefully, you’ll find it funny too. Learning doesn’t always look how you think it should look.
My son, at aged eight through eleven, designed these units. They are based on his interests and motivations. I, however, wrote them out to resemble the curriculum design you might find in popular teacher’s editions or homeschooling manuals. They are written this way in order to help parents feel more comfortable with learning that might look like chaos or wasting time to the inexperienced observer.
Many of these “Units” are an amalgamation of different experiences. For example, we went to the beach many times, but I just wrote one beach themed unit. All of the lessons you find there took place in repeated visits. Please don’t try to squeeze too much learning into one trip. For learning to be self-directed, the learner will pass by many learning opportunities and only partake of the ones that interest them. It’s OK. They can take advantage of missed opportunities later when they are ready, or, they may pass that opportunity by and never look back. It can be hard on parents. It’s only natural that we want our kids to appreciate all the same things that we do, but alas, they are individuals and not our little clones. I have learned to go ahead and point things out that are interesting, but try to keep the lecturing to a minimum.
Please keep in mind that each child and family structure is different. This is in no way a set of “instructions” to follow so that you will unschool the “right way”. This is simply an example of what we did. I supported my son’s learning in any way that I could. I provided guidance in the form of safety limitations. I assisted him by providing materials, transportation, access to information and explanations of concepts using my past experience, but the motivation and focus were all his. Or in many cases, life just happened, and in coping with it, we learned some things. More than anything…I suggest watching and listening.
In addition to these “Units” we spent plenty of time reading, playing games, going on trips, enjoying park days, shopping, cooking and having plenty of time for deep conversations and free play in enriched environments.
How Standards and Standardized Tests Work.
As a teacher, I spent plenty of time analyzing testing data… and I am here to tell you… Don’t worry about Education Standards. Trends change. Every state is different. They are all trying to prove that the taxes people are paying are worth it, so they spend lots of time collecting data to justify their expenses. High test scores benefit the schools and the teachers, but not the kids.
Let me let you in on a secret…
None of it matters except for the graduation test (and that is even debatable). Plenty of kids are getting into college without it and plenty of employers don’t really care either.
Look…all of the state standards and national standards are sort of built the same way. They make a list of skills a graduate needs to know, then they create a thirteen year plan for making sure everybody has been taught these skills. Then they tell the schools, “Prove you are working toward these skills.” The only way the schools can do this efficiently is through standardized testing. The whole process ends up becoming quite redundant and tedious. You end up with something that looks like this…
Standard - Graduates need to understand complex sentence structure.
Kindergarten - Students know that sentences need a subject and predicate. - 1 hour
First Grade - Students will identify subjects and predicates. - 1 hour
Second Grade - Students will write sentences using subjects and predicates. - 1 hour
Third Grade - Students will identify complex subjects and predicates. - 1 hour
Fourth Grade - Students will write sentences using complex subjects and predicates. - 1 hour
Fifth Grade - Students will use appropriate pronoun order for subjects and objects in a sentence. -1 hour
Sixth Grade - Students will use appropriate punctuation for compound and complex sentences. - 1 hour
Seventh Grade - Students will identify simple subjects and predicates in complex and compound sentences. - 1 hour
Eighth Grade - Students will write complex and compound sentences with appropriate pronoun order and clarifying detail. - 1 hour
Ninth Grade - Same - 1 hour
Tenth Grade - Same - 1 hour
Eleventh Grade - Same - 1 hour
Twelfth Grade - Same - 1 hour
So we commonly spend 13 hours or more (honestly, it’s a lot more) teaching and testing kids on sentence structure in a direct instruction setting while they could be learning most of it by having conversations with people who listen and respond appropriately. Think about it… If you spend most of your time sitting quietly in class, how much practice are you really getting on using complex sentence structure?
Here is how an unschooler might learn the same thing.
Lesson 1 (age 5 to 7)
Kid: “Me and him went to the store.”
Caring designated adult: “You should say, “He and I went to the store.”
Kid: “OK. He and I…”
This lesson takes approximately 30 seconds. (It and others like it may need to be repeated)
Lesson 2 (age 9 to 12)
Kid tells a story about something that are excited about. It makes no sense because they are skipping important details.
Caring designated adult: “I don’t know what you are talking about. You need to give me all the details and slow down so I can understand.
Kid naturally amends the story so that he/she is understood.
This lesson takes about 10 minutes (it and others like it may need to be repeated)
Lesson 3 (age 17 or so)
Because you have chosen to take this graduation test, you should probably study for it. It says you will need to identify the subject and predicate in a sentence. Look at the examples. The subject is the thing. The predicate is what the thing does. The object is the thing in the predicate that is having the action done to it. Take out all the other details. Done.
This lesson takes about 10 minutes. A little practice with complex sentences is a good idea. Maybe a half hour or so. If you have been reading and speaking English to this kid for the past 17 years, they’ll basically have it down.
All together unschoolers will have spent about one hour on this specific standard… or seventeen years, depending on how you look at it. The major difference is a dedicated and caring adult and some one-on-one time in an enriched environment with plenty of time for reading and conversation.
If you're really worried about it, I suggest that you look at the practice tests for graduation in your state rather than looking at each year’s state standards. If you can pass the graduation exam, you can teach your kid to pass it if they want to. If you need help, you can seek help for the few concepts that might challenge you.
Online tutorials are awesome, concise and usually free.
This explanation may seem overly simplified, but I challenge you to go to your state department of education website and find the matrix of grade level standards (They all have slightly different names for it). You’ll see the repetition of skills. They might call it “scaffolding” or “spiraling”, but really it is a “teach it over and over until everybody gets it” strategy instead of a “teach it when the kid is ready and they’ll remember it strategy”.
From Pro-School to No-School (My story)
I was raised in a very pro-school family. My parents were both teachers. Most of my parent’s friends were teachers. My aunts were both teachers. My best friend’s mother was a teacher. My brother even married a teacher. I had always been a good student and for the most part enjoyed going to school…but I was frustrated by it too.
I remember, when I was in the third grade, asking my mother if I could just get dropped off at the library instead of going to school. I told her that I thought I could learn more there because school was boring. She promptly had me tested for the gifted program.
Ahhh…if only I had started my unschooling journey then.
Fast forward a bit…
I graduated, went to college, didn’t know what I wanted to study, knew I liked kids, but didn’t want to be a teacher. You see, although my family was very much pro-school, I had heard them complaining about the education system my entire life. Most of their complaints had to do with wasted money and silly top-down management demands that had little to do with actually meeting the needs of individual students. Then there were always stories about classroom management issues, health and hygiene issues, relationships with families, and the frustration that there was never time to meet all of the needs of all of the students. Don’t get me wrong, there were plenty of success stories and funny stories too….but not enough to make me want to become a teacher.
During and after college I worked several jobs… a clerk at a medical management agency, a costume shop assistant, an art department safety assistant, a camp counselor, a youth care worker at an emergency shelter, a floor manager of a science center…and, for whatever reason, I was consistently promoted to the “teaching/training” position in all of them. I finally decided that If I was going to be teaching, I might as well get the benefits that came with it. I started substitute teaching while I worked on my credential. It was during this time, I found myself in a long-term position at a high-school. (After one day of “nothing going wrong” they gave me the position for the rest of the year)
It was at this high-school that I met my first “unschooler”. He didn’t know he was an unschooler. I didn’t either. I had never heard of unschooling. At that point in time I referred to him as an “at risk” kid who was about to drop out. His name was Anthony. He was a big, quiet 17 year old kid who rarely came to school. I was his English teacher. One day, just before progress reports were supposed to come out, he finally showed up. I pulled him aside after class and explained to him that I had to send out progress reports soon and I didn’t have any scores in my record book for him. He hadn’t turned in any assignments and had been absent for every test.
I remember saying, “Anthony, I know you’re a smart kid. I’m willing to help you. Can you stay after school sometime this week and just turn in one test? Or can you at least write something for me to grade? I can’t pass you without any grades. It’s your senior year. I want you to graduate.”
He very sweetly replied, “I don’t want to offend you or anything. You’re a nice teacher and I know you’re just trying to help me…but…school is kind of a waste of my time. You see, my uncle is a plumber. He pays me to help him with his job. I’m learning a lot every day and I’m making good money. My mom really needs help with money right now… You are teaching Shakespeare. I don’t need Shakespeare in my life. I need to learn how to be a plumber. It is a really good job. Working with my uncle is better for my future. Today is my last day. I’m dropping out.”
I didn’t quite know how to respond. He was absolutely right. My Shakespeare lessons weren’t really serving his needs at all… but that was what was in the curriculum. It’s what I had to teach. I didn’t know what else to say, so I just said, “Thanks for letting me know. Good luck.”
I never saw Anthony again…but I think about him often.
The system hadn’t really failed Anthony, but it wasn’t really there to help him either. At 17 he knew what he wanted, had a plan for how to achieve it, and the will to make it happen. He hadn’t gained those qualities or any guidance from school. He learned all of that from his family, himself and by observing the world around him. According to the school, he was a complete failure with low grades and a pitiful attendance record…but I could see a brave young man making thoughtful decisions and preparing himself for a successful future.
Kudos Anthony. Your example will forever be with me.
Fast forward 15 more years… By this time I had subbed or taught everything from Pre-K to Adult school including English as a second language, special education and gifted education. I had settled in an elementary school teaching gifted fifth and sixth graders… my students for the most part did well on their tests and were at or above grade level. I was considered a successful teacher according to the data, but something was wrong. I felt like I wasn’t really helping these kids discover who they wanted to be. I wasn’t helping them with their personal goals. I wasn’t really inspiring them to do anything meaningful in their lives…or if I did, I was off task and not doing my job the way in which I was expected. My students were performing to make me happy, to make their parents proud, to earn a grade, to compete. They were doing well according to the public education system…but something was missing. They weren’t doing this work for themselves or for the love of knowledge. It was like living in a false reality. It bothered me.
Don’t get me wrong. I loved my students. I loved their parents. I loved my Math team and my science fair and my living history museum project and my Artist’s workshop. I loved organizing projects and watching performances and encouraging creativity. I actually enjoyed parent conferences and lived for Open House. I loved field trips, especially Outdoor Science School when we took the kids to live in the mountains for a week. When they took away the music program, I wrote three musicals based on the state Science, Math and Social Studies standards so my kids could still be allowed to sing and perform. I looked forward to the teachers vs. Sixth graders softball game each year. I even enjoyed reading essay after essay in challengingly legible cursive. I was one of those teachers whose car was still in the parking lot at 6pm almost every evening. I poured my life into my classroom and I think my students and their families knew it and appreciated it. I was always overwhelmed with gifts and lovely notes for Christmas and Teacher Appreciation Day. Every day, I felt like a movie star. Kids were always saying, “Hi Mrs. Shepherd” and even running up to give me a hug. It was kind of surreal.
There was a dark side though…and it was growing. Testing was becoming ever more present and important. Intervention programs were being implemented. Competitive reading programs popped up. School-wide behavior programs with incentives started to be everywhere. Teachers were increasingly pulled out of their classrooms and replaced with subs in order to have dialogues (discussions about their students rather than spending the time with their students) School was starting to be stressful and much less personal, for students and teachers alike.
I still remember clearly one of my grade level dialogue meetings. We were discussing reading comprehension test scores. Our scores were confusing because one week half of our kids aced comprehension and the next week the opposite kids aced the comprehension and the first half failed. How could the scores flip flop like that? Actually it was pretty simple. One week the story was about baseball and the next week the story was about girls planning a party. The kids who liked baseball aced the comprehension for the story they were interested in. They failed comprehension when they were disinterested. Duh. We were supposed to come up with strategies to teach the comprehension skills that kids didn't understand. I suggested having the students read things that interested them. We all had a good laugh. Following student interest is simply not an option.
One of the things I liked least about my teaching position was PE. At our school, we didn’t have the funds for a separate PE teacher. I had never really enjoyed PE myself as a child and after teaching all day, I was supposed to take my kids out to get some exercise. I was never much of a sporty person. I didn’t know the rules to all the games. Our usual routine was to do some stretches, run a lap and then vote on a game to play. We usually ended up playing either soccer or dodge ball. What normally would happen is, most kids didn’t really care to play at all, five or six kids who loved soccer would convince them to all choose soccer. We’d all go out onto the field and the six kids would run circles around everyone else. Most of the class just stood around talking to one another and I would be on the sidelines trying to encourage everyone to “get all excited” about the game. I think I usually got more exercise than most of the kids. I’d be jumping up and down yelling, “Go, Go, Go”, and they’d just wait for the bell to ring.
One day, during PE, an amazing thing happened…
I was standing on the sidelines of one such soccer game, 24 kids were standing around and six were expertly playing soccer (like the semi-pros that they were) when I saw out of the corner of my eye…all the way across campus…senior citizen volunteers were carrying large cardboard voting booths out of the multipurpose room and were heading for the recycle dumpster!
“Quick!”, I yelled to six kids who were just standing around. “Hurry and get those voting booths before they throw them out! We can use them for projects!”
The kids ran the length of the school across the field and blacktop over to the volunteers. I could see by their body language that they were politely, but emphatically telling the volunteers that their teacher wanted to save the large cardboard partitions. The 8’x4’ trifold cardboard monstrosities were handed over. Each kid was struggling to carry their load. One kid took the lead and showed the rest how to tuck it under your arm and drag it. They followed his example until they got to the middle of the basketball courts.
Just then the Southern California Santa Ana winds suddenly rushed in. There was a pretty good gust and all of the cardboard went flying. The kids all screamed and chased after them. Each was able to catch their piece and hold on to it in a different way. One was dragging it and walking backwards, one had his under his arm, one had hers balanced on her head, another just hugged it and was walking forward but couldn’t see. And two had completely unfolded their pieces, stacked them and were working as a team. Another gust came. The cardboard flew again. The screaming became laughing, then planning, then experimenting. They were problem solving, collaborating, coming up with creative solutions, justifying their reasoning…all of this while having a good time and getting plenty of exercise!
When they finally stood in front of me covered in sweat, out of breath and giggling, I stood there in awe!
This!
This is what we should be doing! This is what was missing!
The creativity, problem solving, collaboration and communication I saw were the skills I wanted to teach. These were the skills I knew they needed to be successful and confident.
Forget the testing! Forget the competition! Forget the data! Forget the labeling!
For the rest of that school year, when asked what they wanted to do for PE, that class overwhelmingly voted to play “cardboard”. Over the next few months they invented all kinds of games. The cardboard became mats for gymnastics and breakdancing, they were made into tunnels for obstacle courses and mazes, they became slalom courses for soccer practice, they were left standing, then kicked down with awesome karate moves, they became slip and slides and giant paper airplanes…. there was no end to the creativity, collaboration and problem solving.
It was during this year, that I began to study how brains learn. Mind you, I already had taken all of the child development classes and education classes required for a teaching credential and a master’s degree in education, but I still didn’t really know what made a person hold on to a piece of information. What made lessons stick? How are we motivated to learn? What makes us care about learning something?
After much deliberation…I realized that the key was intrinsic motivation… and that intrinsically motivated activities, no matter what they are, are really all forms of play.
I became kind of obsessed with the idea that play was more valuable than direct instruction when it comes to learning. Play is more powerful, more memorable, self adjusting and simply more fun! Play comes naturally. No coercion is necessary. And it is really how we learn the best!
Any preschool teacher can tell you that play is a valuable learning tool…essential even… but somewhere along the line…we decided that at around age six…play stops and direct instruction starts…and that playing is really all about “letting out your energy” so that you can get back to “real” learning.
But wait…shouldn’t we be using all of that energy to enhance our learning? Why would we make ourselves tired in order to be able to sit still to learn something? I had some pretty serious questions about playing and learning…and I wasn’t just thinking about pre-school kids..I was thinking about life-long learning. “Life-long learning” being a huge buzz word at the time. As teachers we were supposed to be encouraging our students to be life-long learners. Yet we were giving them the message that playing and learning were opposites. In truth, life long learning is an individual’s play legacy.
This was becoming a major philosophical hurdle for a teacher in the public education system.
Oh…and during this time, my four-year-old son was regularly getting in trouble for playing around too much at the wrong times in his pre-school. It was suggested that he had ADHD because he couldn’t attend to direct instruction.
So…I decided to take a leave of absence from teaching and go back to school and also to give more attention to my son. I started an on-line Study of Play Master’s Degree program from a University in the UK…because universities in the US don’t really have Play Study Programs…or at least I couldn’t find one.
Over the next few years, while I worked on my Master’s of Play Degree, my son went to school. I watched him go from a playful little boy with lots of questions and ideas to share, to a kid who thought he was “bad and stupid” (His words not mine).
We switched schools a few times to try to find the right fit, but he was always in trouble for playing instead of working and questioning authority. He was also tired, frustrated and sad. At one point he actually told me that he felt like he didn’t belong in this world. He was in Kindergarten! It broke my heart. He didn’t enjoy going to school at all, and quite frankly, I didn’t think his teachers enjoyed him being there either.
We tried different types of classroom settings, but nothing seemed to be an appropriate fit.
I can’t believe I waited so long, but I finally took him out of school mid second grade. I should have done it earlier ( I’ve heard so many parents say this) but my pro-school training made me so afraid. (and…I had to leave my teaching career too) After I brought him home to homeschool, it wasn’t long before I realized that school at home wasn’t going to work either.
I still remember sitting at the dining room table with my lap top trying to figure out which curriculum we should use when my son began to create his own…
This is fab. Love it. Who wrote this? Author not listed!
ReplyDeleteOh. Hi. Kristin Shepherd here...guess I need to fix that. Thanks.
ReplyDeleteI am also a trained teacher, but with fewer years in the classroom. This is our first year unschooling. We went from public school to school at home to this. My hope in homeschooling my oldest was she would learn to take charge of her learning. Ha! That didn't work with my telling her what she had to learn. I love seeing them excited about what they are doing. We are still very much deschooling, but they are already choosing to do some cool, fun stuff, that most people would respect as learning. I'm learning to let go and stop caring about the status quo.
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for sharing your story. It’s reassuring as I have taken my 7-year-old and 9-year-old out of school this year. After reading about the different homeschooling philosophies, trying out different curriculum in the morning, and then listening to countless unschoolers describe their kids self-directed learning, I was sold. I am still trying to de-school myself. My kids still have to put up with 30 minutes of one-on-one teaching with someone in some other part of the world on my pre-ply app (subject mostly of my choosing from Spanish to math), but then they get the rest of the day to decide what they want to learn. Please keep blogging. You are a source of inspiration and reassurance.
ReplyDelete